Close Menu
    Jennifer MehditashJennifer Mehditash
    • Kitchen
    • Curb Appeal
    • Paint & Color
    • Living Room
    • Floors & Tile
    • Tools
    • About
      • Contact
      • Editorial Guidelines
      • Affiliate Disclosure
      • Privacy Policy
    Jennifer MehditashJennifer Mehditash
    Home » Comparisons » Insl-X Cabinet Coat vs Benjamin Moore Advance: Which Cabinet Paint to Choose
    Comparisons

    Insl-X Cabinet Coat vs Benjamin Moore Advance: Which Cabinet Paint to Choose

    Lisa JamesonBy Lisa JamesonMay 23, 20246 Mins Read
    Facebook Pinterest Email
    White painted kitchen cabinets with plants on top
    Share
    Facebook Pinterest Email

    Some links on this page are affiliate links (for example Amazon). If you buy through them I may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you. How this works.

    Contents show
    1 The short answer
    2 How the two formulas differ
    3 Why Advance looks so smooth
    4 Why Cabinet Coat is popular with DIYers
    5 The prep that matters more than the paint
    6 Application tips for each paint
    7 Which one I would pick
    8 Frequently asked questions

    If you are repainting kitchen cabinets yourself, two names come up again and again: Insl-X Cabinet Coat and Benjamin Moore Advance. Both are water-cleanup enamels made for cabinets, trim and furniture, and both can give you a smooth, hard-wearing finish. They behave quite differently on the brush, though, and that difference should drive your choice more than the label.

    This guide compares the two honestly, explains what actually makes a cabinet paint job last, and helps you pick the one that suits your kitchen, your schedule and your patience.

    The short answer

    • Choose Benjamin Moore Advance if you want the smoothest possible brushed finish and you can live with long waits between coats. It is a waterborne alkyd, so it levels out like an oil paint and dries slowly.
    • Choose Insl-X Cabinet Coat if you want to finish faster, are spraying, or are working in a kitchen you need back quickly. It is a urethane-acrylic enamel that dries and recoats much sooner.
    • Whichever you pick, prep and primer matter more than the topcoat. A great paint over a greasy, glossy, unprimed door will still chip.

    Insl-X is part of the Benjamin Moore family of brands, so this is less a battle between rival companies and more a choice between two different formulas.

    How the two formulas differ

    Benjamin Moore AdvanceInsl-X Cabinet Coat
    TypeWaterborne alkyd (oil-like resin that cleans up with water)Urethane-modified acrylic enamel
    Feel on the brushThin, slow, levels out brush marksThicker, sets up faster
    Recoat timeLong: Benjamin Moore’s data sheet lists 16 hoursShort: a few hours in normal conditions
    Cure to full hardnessWeeks, be gentle with doors at firstAlso weeks, but feels hard sooner
    SheensMatte, satin, semi-gloss, high glossTypically satin and semi-gloss
    Best forBrush-and-roll jobs where finish quality is the priorityFaster projects, spraying, busy households

    Data-sheet figures change, and temperature and humidity affect drying a lot, so always check the current technical data sheet for the exact product and sheen you buy.

    Why Advance looks so smooth

    Advance’s selling point is leveling. Because the alkyd resin stays wet longer, brush strokes have time to flatten before the film sets. On flat slab doors and smooth frames, a careful painter can get a finish that looks close to sprayed.

    The trade-off is time. With a 16-hour recoat, a typical two-coat job on a full kitchen takes several days, and doors need careful handling for a few weeks while the paint cures. Advance can also yellow slightly over time in low-light spots, like any alkyd-type paint, which is worth knowing if you are using a bright white.

    Why Cabinet Coat is popular with DIYers

    Cabinet Coat dries faster and is more forgiving if you are short on time. You can usually get two coats on in a day, which matters when your kitchen is out of action. It also sprays well with an HVLP sprayer or an airless with a fine-finish tip.

    The trade-off is that it does not level as much on the brush. If you are brushing, use a good synthetic brush and a fine foam or microfiber roller on flat areas, and resist going back over areas that have started to set.

    The prep that matters more than the paint

    Most failed cabinet paint jobs fail because of prep, not because of the brand. Before any topcoat:

    1. Label and remove doors, drawer fronts and hardware. Painting doors flat avoids runs.
    2. Degrease thoroughly. Kitchen cabinets carry a film of cooking grease, especially near the stove. Use a degreasing cleaner and rinse with clean water.
    3. Scuff sand the existing finish with fine sandpaper (around 180 to 220 grit) so the primer has something to grip. You are dulling the sheen, not stripping it.
    4. Fill dents and open grain with wood filler, then sand smooth. Oak grain will show through paint unless you fill it with a grain filler.
    5. Vacuum and wipe with a tack cloth or damp microfiber.
    6. Prime with a bonding primer. Insl-X Stix is a waterborne bonding primer that grips glossy surfaces. A shellac-based primer is a good choice over knotty or tannin-rich wood that might bleed through.

    If your cabinets are thermofoil or laminate, check the primer label carefully. Not every product is rated for those surfaces, and peeling thermofoil cannot be fixed with paint.

    Kitchen with dark teal cabinets, a white island and patterned floor tiles

    Application tips for each paint

    For Advance:

    • Stir well and do not shake. Thin coats work better than thick ones.
    • Brush or roll a section, then lightly tip it off in one direction and leave it alone. Overworking ruins the leveling.
    • Keep the room warm and dry. Cold or humid conditions stretch the drying time even further.

    For Cabinet Coat:

    • Work in smaller sections and keep a wet edge, because it sets faster.
    • If spraying, practise on cardboard first and strain the paint.
    • Lightly sand between coats with a fine sanding sponge for the smoothest result.

    For both: reinstall doors only when the paint is dry enough not to stick, and use clear bumper pads on door corners. Treat the finish gently for the first few weeks while it cures.

    Which one I would pick

    For a brush-and-roll kitchen where the finish has to look as smooth as possible, and you can spread the work over a long weekend or more, Advance is the stronger choice. For a family kitchen that needs to be back in use quickly, or if you are spraying, Cabinet Coat makes life easier and still gives a durable finish.

    If you are still deciding on a color, our blue kitchen cabinet ideas and color schemes for white cabinets are good places to start, and you can see how other homeowners handled the same job in our roundup of real kitchen makeovers from home bloggers. If you are weighing up painting versus keeping wood, our hickory vs maple cabinet comparison explains how each wood takes paint and stain.

    Frequently asked questions

    How many coats do cabinets need?

    Plan on a primer coat plus two finish coats for most color changes. Very dark-to-light changes can need a third coat. Thin coats level better and dry harder than one thick coat.

    Should I spray or brush cabinet paint?

    Spraying gives the smoothest finish but needs masking, equipment and practice. A good synthetic brush for edges and a fine foam or microfiber roller for flat panels gives a very good result for most DIYers.

    Do I need a primer with Benjamin Moore Advance or Cabinet Coat?

    On previously finished cabinets, yes. A bonding primer is the cheapest insurance you can buy against chipping and peeling.

    Can I use either paint on bathroom vanities?

    Yes. Both are suitable for vanities. Make sure the room is well ventilated while painting and let the paint cure before heavy use.

    How long should I wait before rehanging doors?

    Wait until the paint is dry to the touch and no longer tacky, and longer for Advance. Then handle the doors carefully for the first few weeks while the finish hardens.

    Which is easier for a beginner?

    Cabinet Coat is usually more forgiving on time, while Advance is more forgiving on brush marks. If you tend to overwork paint, Advance will punish that. If you are slow and methodical, it rewards you.

    Lisa Jameson

    Written by Lisa Jameson

    Lisa is a contributor who writes many of the exterior makeover and paint color guides here.

    More about Lisa · How guides are written and updated

    Share. Facebook Pinterest Email
    Lisa Jameson
    Lisa Jameson
    • Website

    Lisa is a contributor who writes many of the exterior makeover and paint color guides on this site.

    Comments are closed.

    Jennifer Mehditash

    Hi, I’m Jennifer. I sort home ideas room by room so you can find the right one faster. About me

    Browse by room

    • Kitchen Ideas
    • Exterior & Curb Appeal
    • Paint & Color
    • Living Room & Furniture
    • Floors, Tile & Countertops

    Free design tools

    • Exterior color pairing helper
    • Rug size calculator

    Some links on this site are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

    Jennifer Mehditash

    Home ideas, room by room: kitchens, curb appeal, paint colors, living rooms and floors, with practical how-to guides.

    Email: contact@jennifermehditash.com

    Follow me on Pinterest

    Browse by room

    • Kitchen Ideas
    • Exterior & Curb Appeal
    • Paint & Color
    • Living Room & Furniture
    • Floors, Tile & Countertops

    Design tools

    • Exterior color pairing helper
    • Rug size calculator

    The site

    • About
    • Contact
    • Editorial guidelines
    • Affiliate disclosure
    • Privacy policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms of use
    © 2026 Jennifer Mehditash. Ideas and how-tos are general guidance; check product instructions and local building rules for your own home.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.